What is Filamentous Algae?
Filamentous algae are connected algae cells that grow and form long threads or filaments When growth is
excessive, large mats can form that stretch from the river bottom to the surface and cover significant
portions of a river reach. The term “Filamentous Algae” refers to any number of species that can be found in
rivers and streams. There are numerous species of algae that are native to West Virginia and that can be
found at any one location.
Impacts of Filamentous Algae Blooms
Filamentous algae blooms can interfere with designated uses of a river - typically water contact recreation
and public water supply. The images display the extent of the problem in some impacted rivers.
If entities supplying public drinking water have an intake located in an area of a filamentous algae bloom,
they commonly receive complaints about the odor and/or taste of the water, requiring additional treatment
and expenditures. Recreational activities, such as swimming and fishing, can be impacted by the excessive
algae, and lessen one's ability to enjoy state rivers and streams.
Recreational Activity and Filamentous Algae in West Virginia Streams
Questions have been raised concerning how filamentous algae in West Virginia streams and rivers impacts and
ultimately may limit recreational activities. Activities like swimming, fishing and boating support a
significant tourism industry and are a critical economic driver in numerous regions of the state. As
important as this issue is, it is very difficult to adequately measure and quantify impacts. To address this
question, DEP sponsored a survey to measure the level of tolerance residents have to varying amounts of
filamentous algae in state streams. The survey was conducted by the research firm Responsive Management, and
a copy of the final report is provided.
What Causes Filamentous Algae to Bloom?
Nutrients - primarily nitrogen and phosphorus - when in excess are directly available and allow normal
background levels of algae to grow into excessive blooms. Flow conditions and river water chemistry also
influence when and where a bloom may occur. Sources of the excessive nutrients vary by watershed, from point
sources such as waste water facilities to non-point sources including urban or agricultural runoff.
What is the DEP Doing to Address Filamentous Algae Blooms?
DEP is monitoring numerous rivers in the state for filamentous algae blooms, including the Greenbrier,
Tygart, South Branch of the Potomac and the Cacapon rivers. The Watershed Assessment Branch (WAB) has
developed Standard Operating Procedures (SOPs) for measuring filamentous algae in streams and rivers. The
SOP can be found in the Periphyton/algae collection procedures section of the SOP document. WAB has also
completed numerous special studies on the algae issues in the Greenbrier River and these studies can be
found on the Special Studies web page. When adequate information is collected that determines blooms are
impacting the uses of a stream or river - DEP will consider listing the waterbody as impaired and putting it
on the 303(d) list. The DEP has developed a listing methodology for determining algae impairments that can
be found in the 303(d) Listing Methodology for Filamentous Algae Blooms. Once listed, DEP will develop a
TMDL or take other actions to address the sources of pollution contributing to the algae blooms. Annual
stream nutrient-algae monitoring and assessment reports can be found on the Nutrient Reports web page.
What can I do if I see Algae Blooms?
DEP staff cannot be everywhere, and input from the public can greatly assist in our understanding of
filamentous algae blooms, including when and where they happen. So if you see something that resembles a
filamentous algae bloom, here is how you can help:
- Document the time and place - the more specific the description the better, but even a general location
is helpful.
- A picture speaks volumes - the more the better.
- Let us know what type of activity you were doing; swimming, fishing, boating, kayaking, etc. Did the
algae impact your activity?
- Contact DEP Staff
Contact Information
James P. Summers, Environmental Resources Analyst
West Virginia Department of Environmental Protection
Division of Water and Waste Management
601 57th Street, SE
Charleston, WV 25304
Phone: (304) 926-0499 x43890
Email: James.P.Summers@wv.gov
303(d) Listing Methodology for Filamentous Algae Blooms
In 2011 the Requirements Governing West Virginia Water Quality Standards (47CSR2) were modified to
include language that prohibited algae blooms which impair or interfere with the designated uses of a
stream. In order to scientifically define what levels of algae would impair or interfere with the uses of a
stream, DEP hired the research firm Responsive Management to survey West Virginians on their tolerance
levels for filamentous riverine algae growth. DEP worked closely with Responsive Management to develop
the public survey of over one thousand West Virginians in 2012.
West Virginia Residents' Opinions On and Tolerance Levels of Algae in West Virginia Waters found that a clear
majority of West Virginians (over 70%) regarded 39% algal cover as impairing their use. Roughly half of the
people regarded 26% algal cover as an impairment. Approximately three fourths (72%) of those surveyed
indicated that algal cover of 20% would not interfere with their use of the stream.
Other factors related to filamentous algae blooms that will affect the recreational use of a stream include
duration of the bloom, frequency of occurrence, filament length, longitudinal extent, percent of water
column filled, and location of the bloom relative to houses, camps, and public access sites.
Further, algae blooms may impair other uses of a stream. DEP has determined that algae blooms have at
times affected some streams' use as a drinking water supply. Specific guidance is also provided in this
document for determining impairment in cases impacting public water supplies (47-2-3.2.d and 3.2.h).
DEP will use the following guidelines to evaluate compliance with the narrative standards and/or determine
impairment of a stream's use(s) caused by filamentous algae blooms:
-
A filamentous algae cover of greater than 20% of the lateral transect area will be judged to interfere
with the recreational use of a stream whenever that bloom extends for a longitudinal distance
greater three times the average stream width in the impacted segment of stream, as determined by
a minimum of three stream measurements taken using the SOP for Filamentous Algae Monitoring
developed by DEP.
-
Except as provided in Guideline 4, a filamentous algae cover of greater than 40% of the lateral
transect area will be judged to interfere with the recreational use of a stream.
-
Whenever a stream has filamentous algae covering more than 20% of a lateral transect area, and the
algae bloom is located immediately adjacent to any occupied dwelling, campground, or developed
public access site, DEP may determine that the recreational use of a stream is impaired after
considering such factors as duration of the bloom, frequency of occurrence, longitudinal extent,
bloom location relative to the stream access site, level of use, type of use, length of filaments, and
size of floating mats.
-
Isolated bloom events include those that are isolated temporally, longitudinally, and/or
geographically. DEP may determine a stream is not impaired when an isolated bloom event exceeds
Guidelines 1-2. In making such a determination DEP will consider the duration of the exceedance,
lifespan and physical characteristics of the algae, longitudinal extent, and percent of the water
column filled. Additionally, DEP will consider available information regarding the flow conditions
during the year of the bloom relative to the normal range of flows2 location of the bloom relative to
other algae blooms, types of access and recreational uses, public complaints, frequency of
occurrence and intensity of the bloom in previous years.
-
Guidelines 1-3 DO NOT apply where the width of a stream (at the ordinary high water mark) is less
than 15 meters wide, or when algae filaments or stalks are less than 5 cm. Guidelines 1-3 are
intended only for nontoxic filamentous algae blooms and do not address, for example, growth of
non-filamentous periphyton, sestonic algae blooms, or bloom events involving toxic or otherwise
harmful algae. This is not to say that these blooms could not ever impair a stream; only that these
blooms are beyond the scope of this guidance.
-
Relating to filamentous or any other algae blooms causing taste or odor that interferes with the use
of the water and/or causing additional (unreasonable) treatment to be required at drinking water
plants, DEP considers any treatment beyond “conventional treatment” (see 47-2-2.1) that is required
as a result of taste and/or odor complaints associated with algae blooms to be grounds for classifying
a stream as impaired (47-2-3.2.h). DEP will also judge a stream to be impaired under 47-2-3.2.d
whenever multiple taste or odor complaints about finished drinking water are documented during
the algae growing season, regardless of whether any additional treatment beyond conventional
treatment is being performed at the drinking water plant.
Rationale for Guidelines
The guidelines developed by DEP for determining impairment represent a balanced, rational, and scientific
approach to maintaining the recreational use of streams that are impacted by filamentous algae blooms.
-
DEP interprets the Responsive Management study to demonstrate that use of a stream is not
impaired by an algal coverage of less than 20%.
-
In the Responsive Management research, 49% of all people surveyed and 52% of boaters (the most
sensitive user group) indicated that a 26% algal coverage of stream would interfere with their use of
the stream. This level of algal development represents the “tipping point” for the majority of people.
However, a stream condition in which half the users find it to be impaired can hardly be considered to
be fully meeting its designated uses. Therefore, DEP is setting the standard for this guideline at a
more protective level. The Responsive Management survey found that when the coverage was
reduced to from 26% to 20%, 3 in 4 people found it to be acceptable. This slightly lower standard
provides protection for another quarter of users.
Recognizing that 20% coverage at a single transect on a stream would not necessarily impair the use
of a stream in all cases, additional guidance on the longitudinal component is provided. Guideline #1
provides an allowance for 20-40% algal coverage for a distance up to three times the average width
(between the ordinary high water marks on the banks) of the stream segment. Given the special
consideration provided for dwellings, campgrounds, and public access sites in Guideline #3, the
longitudinal allowance is meant to provide a reasonable limit to the distance that boaters and
fisherman would encounter potentially undesirable levels of algae. The length of the longitudinal
component is also a practical limit to what can typically be assessed without having to use a boat in
the assessment.
-
Guideline #2 establishes a general “ceiling” for algae cover on a stream. It is made necessary
especially by the longitudinal allowance given in Guideline #1 (3X river width). For example, a 200
foot wide river with 22% bottom cover may still be considered acceptable for wading and fishing if
the bloom persists even for 500 feet, but use of a river that is 80% covered by algae for 500 feet is
impaired significantly. There needs to be some upper limit for this longitudinal allowance. There is
near universal agreement3
that 47% coverage impairs use of a stream. The ceiling established by this
guideline (40% coverage) establishes a reasonable limit to the amount of algae that can cover a
stream in the longitudinal allowance provided in Guideline #1.
-
Most boaters and fisherman are mobile river users, often floating stream reaches several miles in
length, where a moderate algae bloom (of limited magnitude as prescribed in Guidelines 1 and 2)
would not significantly impact their use. However, DEP recognizes that special consideration may be
needed for river uses associated with fixed locations like residences or a public access sites. A
property owner should be able to utilize the river bordering his property and all should be able to
utilize the stream at public access sites.
Implementation of Guidelines 1 and 2 may result in a limited distance algae bloom, considered
unacceptable by the majority, to overlap fixed use locations. As such, Guideline #3 provides
flexibility to determine use impairment associated with algae coverage of magnitudes less that the
thresholds established in Guidelines 1 and 2 when the impacted zone is located adjacent to
dwellings, campgrounds, or developed public access sites. Whenever the coverage exceeds 20% at
these sites, DEP may make a site specific determination of use impairment after considering the
described factors.
-
The severity of an algae bloom may be measured in essentially four dimensions: lateral coverage
(width), longitudinal extent (length), water column fill (depth), and duration (time). As any of the
dimensions increase the bloom would be considered more severe; and as any of the dimensions
decrease the bloom would be considered less severe. Guidelines 1-2 are primarily concerned4 with
only one of the dimensions - lateral coverage - since this was the dimension evaluated by the public
survey. Guideline 4 establishes a mechanism by which DEP has a limited degree of flexibility in
considering these other dimensions and variables, when an isolated algae bloom occurs
Guideline 4 applies ONLY to “isolated bloom events”. These blooms are isolated temporally,
longitudinally, and/or geographically. For example, DEP may evaluate 10 miles of a river and
encounter an isolated algae bloom covering 42% of the river and extending for only 50 feet. A strict
application of Guideline 2 would deem the recreational use of this river impaired. Consider also that
the bloom may be a species of algae with a shorter life span, which results in a short lived bloom that
peaked above the listing threshold for only 5-7 days. Crafting guidelines to specifically address every
possible variable would result in a lengthy, complicated set of Guidelines. Instead, DEP has opted to
provide some room for flexibility and professional judgement in those very limited circumstances
where an isolated bloom event occurs.
-
The Responsive Management survey only utilized photos of moderate to large river with long strand
filamentous algae blooms to determine tolerance levels of algae coverage in a stream. Applying the
results of this study to other types of algae, or to smaller streams, would not be appropriate.
Periphyton, for example, could cover 100% of a stream bottom without interfering with the
recreational use of the stream.
-
Algae blooms, and particularly the decomposition of algae, can cause a strong musty, earthy, or
grassy odor in drinking water. This odor is not removed during conventional drinking water
treatment processes (sedimentation, filtration, and disinfection) and causes a similar taste in the
finished drinking water. The odor and taste issues associated with algae blooms are often attributed
to the presence of geosmin and MIB (2-Methylisoborneol), which can be smelled at a very low (parts
per trillion) level. To reduce the unpleasant taste and odor caused by the algal blooms, activated
carbon is often used as an absorption media; potassium permanganate may also be added as an
oxidizing agent to reduce odor. Each of these chemical additives is removed during the treatment
process prior to delivery of treated water supply.
47CSR2-3.2.d lists “Taste or odor that would adversely affect the designated uses of the affected
waters” as a Condition Not Allowable in state waters. Whenever the characteristic taste or odor
complaints are received about water supplied from systems where the intake is located within or
immediately downstream of the zone of an algae bloom, and there is an indication that the odor is
caused by the algae bloom, DEP may classify the stream as impaired whenever such complaints are
received - regardless of whether they are corrected by the addition of chemicals to the treatment
process.
Taste and odor complaints are not limited to filamentous algae blooms, but can also be associated
with sestonic algae, phytoplanktonic algae, or algal periphyton.
Listing and Delisting Decisions
If DEP determines that the use of a stream has been impaired in the same segment (Assessment Unit) for two
consecutive years, or two out of three years, DEP will include that stream segment in the Section 303(d) List
of Impaired Streams West Virginia.
A stream which has been placed on the state's 303(d) List of Impaired Streams due to algae blooms may after
a time no longer exhibit such blooms. This may be due to various factors such as changes in causative
sources (treatment plant upgrades, BMP implementation, etc.), changes in stream chemistry (particularly
alkalinity or hardness), and/or physical alterations (natural or manmade). DEP will not consider delisting a
stream when the diminished algae growth is due primarily to an annual variation in rainfall, i.e., excessive
rainfall and streamflow during the algae growing season that lessens the severity of algae blooms will not be
considered grounds for removing a stream from the 303(d) list.
For a stream which was previously listed under these guidelines because of impairment of the stream's
recreational use, DEP will consider removing a stream from the 303(d) list when one of the following
conditions are met:
-
DEP has evaluated the extent of algal growth during critical flow conditions in locations
historically susceptible to blooms for a minimum of five consecutive years and found no blooms
which would have caused the stream to be listed as impaired for recreational use.
-
Specific measures have been implemented to significantly reduce nutrient loading from known
causative sources, or which otherwise work to control the growth of algae, and DEP has
evaluated the extent of algal growth during critical flow conditions in locations historically
susceptible to blooms for a minimum of three consecutive years. During the three years of
evaluation, no blooms were observed which would have caused the stream to be listed as
impaired.
DEP will consider removing a stream from the 303(d) list which was previously listed under these guidelines
because of impairment of the stream's use as a drinking water source when:
-
For a period of three consecutive years, taste and odor complaints associated with algae blooms
are alleviated and no treatment beyond “conventional treatment” (see 47-2-2.1) is required at
the drinking water treatment facility.
Footnotes
-
Amended November 1, 2016 and March 1, 2022
-
Low flow events do not negate the narrative standard; but an evaluation of the flow compared to other years may give
an indication of the frequency that similar bloom events might be expected to occur.
-
The Responsive Management study found that 87% of all people surveyed indicated that a 47% algal coverage in a
stream's transect would interfere with their use of a stream.
-
Guideline 1 does address longitudinal extent of blooms in some circumstances.